MLB Betting Analyzer — Full Audit

Saturday, July 18 2026

MARKET TRUST TIERS

17 market(s) with settled tracker history
MarketTrustSeason NSeason WRSeason P&L14d N14d WR14d P&LGrade A NGrade A WRReview-only N
K Propβœ… TRUSTED41257%+0.28u5250%-6.58u19060%64
Pitcher Hits Allowedβœ… TRUSTED36360%+20.97u4963%+4.99u450%6
Run Lineβœ… TRUSTED13854%-3.08u0-+0.00u4163%1
Batter WalksπŸ‘€ WATCH62772%-9.06u0-+0.00u580%134
Pitcher Earned RunsπŸ‘€ WATCH34160%+4.33u7666%+8.59u1100%9
Pitcher WalksπŸ‘€ WATCH24960%-8.84u6462%+0.20u0-11
Batter HitsπŸ‘€ WATCH3778%+3.90u0-+0.00u0-23
Batter Total BasesπŸ‘€ WATCH3155%+0.66u0-+0.00u0-37
F5 MLπŸ‘€ WATCH2848%+4.54u0-+0.00u0-0
No HR U1.5πŸ‘€ WATCH922%-5.18u0-+0.00u0-0
MoneylineπŸ‘€ WATCH650%+2.85u0-+0.00u0-0
NRFIπŸ‘€ WATCH333%+0.00u0-+0.00u0-0
YRFIπŸ‘€ WATCH2100%+0.00u0-+0.00u0-0
Pitcher OutsπŸ”¬ RESEARCH10346%-13.54u633%-2.52u250%8
TotalπŸ”¬ RESEARCH5038%-10.52u0-+0.00u1100%7
F5 TotalπŸ”¬ RESEARCH10%-1.00u0-+0.00u0-6
Batter H+R+RBIβ›” PAUSED48450%-56.69u0-+0.00u7053%355

Raw edge is an uncalibrated ranking/debug signal. Trust tiers come from Best/Good settled tracker performance; review-only rows are shown separately.

MARKET PROMOTION CRITERIA

What each market needs to move stages
MarketCurrent StageNext StageProgressPromotion Blockers
K Propβœ… TRUSTEDMaintain Trusted3/414d P&L non-negative
Pitcher Hits Allowedβœ… TRUSTEDMaintain Trusted4/4No blocker
Run Lineβœ… TRUSTEDMaintain Trusted2/4season P&L non-negative; 14d sample >= 10
Batter WalksπŸ‘€ WATCHβœ… Trusted2/5season P&L positive; 14d sample >= 10; Grade A sample >= 20 and WR >= 55% or Grade B sample >= 50, WR >= 55%, P&L > 0
Pitcher Earned RunsπŸ‘€ WATCHβœ… Trusted5/5No blocker
Pitcher WalksπŸ‘€ WATCHβœ… Trusted3/5season P&L positive; Grade A sample >= 20 and WR >= 55% or Grade B sample >= 50, WR >= 55%, P&L > 0
Batter HitsπŸ‘€ WATCHβœ… Trusted2/5season sample >= 50; 14d sample >= 10; Grade A sample >= 20 and WR >= 55% or Grade B sample >= 50, WR >= 55%, P&L > 0
Batter Total BasesπŸ‘€ WATCHβœ… Trusted2/5season sample >= 50; 14d sample >= 10; Grade A sample >= 20 and WR >= 55% or Grade B sample >= 50, WR >= 55%, P&L > 0
F5 MLπŸ‘€ WATCHβœ… Trusted2/5season sample >= 50; 14d sample >= 10; Grade A sample >= 20 and WR >= 55% or Grade B sample >= 50, WR >= 55%, P&L > 0
No HR U1.5πŸ‘€ WATCHβœ… Trusted1/5season sample >= 50; season P&L positive; 14d sample >= 10
MoneylineπŸ‘€ WATCHβœ… Trusted2/5season sample >= 50; 14d sample >= 10; Grade A sample >= 20 and WR >= 55% or Grade B sample >= 50, WR >= 55%, P&L > 0
NRFIπŸ‘€ WATCHβœ… Trusted1/5season sample >= 50; season P&L positive; 14d sample >= 10
YRFIπŸ‘€ WATCHβœ… Trusted1/5season sample >= 50; season P&L positive; 14d sample >= 10
Pitcher OutsπŸ”¬ RESEARCHπŸ‘€ Watch1/5season P&L positive; 14d sample >= 10; 14d WR >= 52%
TotalπŸ”¬ RESEARCHπŸ‘€ Watch1/5season P&L positive; 14d sample >= 10; 14d WR >= 52%
F5 TotalπŸ”¬ RESEARCHπŸ‘€ Watch0/5season sample >= 50; season P&L positive; 14d sample >= 10
Batter H+R+RBIβ›” PAUSEDπŸ”¬ Research2/5diagnostic/component model has settled validation; season P&L non-negative; 14d sample >= 10

Promotion criteria keep markets from getting stuck in purgatory: each stage has explicit evidence needed for the next stage.

SAVANT PITCH QUALITY DIAGNOSTICS

30 pitcher(s) with public-data pitch-quality diagnostics
PitcherGameOverallWhiffContactArsenalTop PitchNotes / Data Gaps
JesΓΊs LuzardoPhiladelphia Phillies vs New York Mets71.673.973.04Sweeper (51% whiff, 37% usage)Savant whiff 33.2%, put-away 23.7%, xwOBA 0.269, arsenal coverage 4 pitch type(s)
Tarik SkubalDetroit Tigers vs Los Angeles Angels66.067.668.55Changeup (49% whiff, 25% usage)Savant whiff 30.8%, put-away 22.3%, xwOBA 0.278, arsenal coverage 5 pitch type(s)
Jared JonesPittsburgh Pirates vs Cleveland Guardians64.972.760.04Changeup (38% whiff, 16% usage)Savant whiff 32.6%, put-away 23.8%, xwOBA 0.295, arsenal coverage 4 pitch type(s)
Shane DrohanMilwaukee Brewers vs Miami Marlins60.959.664.56Slider (39% whiff, 21% usage)Savant whiff 27.7%, put-away 20.5%, xwOBA 0.286, arsenal coverage 6 pitch type(s)
Patrick SandovalBoston Red Sox vs Tampa Bay Rays60.464.760.55Changeup (44% whiff, 28% usage)Savant whiff 21.8%, put-away 37.4%, xwOBA 0.294, arsenal coverage 5 pitch type(s)
Ian SeymourTampa Bay Rays vs Boston Red Sox59.761.262.07Sweeper (37% whiff, 25% usage)Savant whiff 28.7%, put-away 20.1%, xwOBA 0.291, arsenal coverage 7 pitch type(s)
Emmet SheehanLos Angeles Dodgers vs New York Yankees58.063.754.54Slider (39% whiff, 30% usage)Savant whiff 30.0%, put-away 19.9%, xwOBA 0.306, arsenal coverage 4 pitch type(s)
Max MeyerMiami Marlins vs Milwaukee Brewers56.259.756.55Slider (40% whiff, 26% usage)Savant whiff 27.8%, put-away 20.4%, xwOBA 0.302, arsenal coverage 5 pitch type(s)
Taj BradleyMinnesota Twins vs Chicago Cubs56.158.255.54Cutter (39% whiff, 24% usage)Savant whiff 27.0%, put-away 20.4%, xwOBA 0.304, arsenal coverage 4 pitch type(s)
Bryan WooSeattle Mariners vs San Francisco Giants55.252.161.55Sweeper (34% whiff, 13% usage)Savant whiff 24.5%, put-away 19.3%, xwOBA 0.292, arsenal coverage 5 pitch type(s)
Logan AllenCleveland Guardians vs Pittsburgh Pirates55.263.054.54Sweeper (50% whiff, 19% usage)Savant whiff 23.1%, put-away 33.1%, xwOBA 0.306, arsenal coverage 4 pitch type(s)
MacKenzie GoreTexas Rangers vs Atlanta Braves54.756.854.56Changeup (35% whiff, 11% usage)Savant whiff 25.9%, put-away 21.3%, xwOBA 0.306, arsenal coverage 6 pitch type(s)
Owen MurphyAtlanta Braves vs Texas Rangers54.135.677.534-Seam Fastball (22% whiff, 60% usage)Savant whiff 18.9%, put-away 14.1%, xwOBA 0.260, arsenal coverage 3 pitch type(s)
Gavin WilliamsCleveland Guardians vs Pittsburgh Pirates53.864.845.55Sweeper (43% whiff, 27% usage)Savant whiff 29.2%, put-away 22.8%, xwOBA 0.324, arsenal coverage 5 pitch type(s)
J.T. GinnAthletics vs Washington Nationals53.659.451.05Changeup (34% whiff, 20% usage)Savant whiff 26.9%, put-away 22.0%, xwOBA 0.313, arsenal coverage 5 pitch type(s)
Ryan WeathersNew York Yankees vs Los Angeles Dodgers53.462.845.55Sweeper (44% whiff, 20% usage)Savant whiff 27.9%, put-away 23.2%, xwOBA 0.324, arsenal coverage 5 pitch type(s)
Dustin MaySt. Louis Cardinals vs Arizona Diamondbacks51.447.557.06Sweeper (34% whiff, 19% usage)Savant whiff 22.4%, put-away 19.0%, xwOBA 0.301, arsenal coverage 6 pitch type(s)
Matthew BoydChicago Cubs vs Minnesota Twins49.762.437.55Slider (51% whiff, 15% usage)Savant whiff 30.1%, put-away 18.5%, xwOBA 0.340, arsenal coverage 5 pitch type(s)
Davis MartinChicago White Sox vs Toronto Blue Jays49.053.646.06Slider (40% whiff, 14% usage)Savant whiff 25.8%, put-away 18.3%, xwOBA 0.323, arsenal coverage 6 pitch type(s)
Griffin CanningSan Diego Padres vs Kansas City Royals47.752.641.07Slider (39% whiff, 25% usage)Savant whiff 24.4%, put-away 20.1%, xwOBA 0.333, arsenal coverage 7 pitch type(s)
Brandon PfaadtArizona Diamondbacks vs St. Louis Cardinals46.747.945.07Curveball (36% whiff, 19% usage)Savant whiff 22.7%, put-away 18.8%, xwOBA 0.325, arsenal coverage 7 pitch type(s)
Logan WebbSan Francisco Giants vs Seattle Mariners46.742.053.05Changeup (28% whiff, 24% usage)Savant whiff 19.8%, put-away 18.6%, xwOBA 0.309, arsenal coverage 5 pitch type(s)
Sean ManaeaNew York Mets vs Philadelphia Phillies46.743.448.55Sweeper (29% whiff, 32% usage)Savant whiff 21.0%, put-away 17.8%, xwOBA 0.318, arsenal coverage 5 pitch type(s)
Trevor RogersBaltimore Orioles vs Houston Astros45.042.047.55Sweeper (31% whiff, 12% usage)Savant whiff 22.7%, put-away 12.9%, xwOBA 0.320, arsenal coverage 5 pitch type(s)
Spencer ArrighettiHouston Astros vs Baltimore Orioles43.956.233.07Curveball (39% whiff, 34% usage)Savant whiff 26.0%, put-away 20.6%, xwOBA 0.349, arsenal coverage 7 pitch type(s)
Rhett LowderCincinnati Reds vs Colorado Rockies37.043.729.04Slider (35% whiff, 27% usage)Savant whiff 20.4%, put-away 19.2%, xwOBA 0.357, arsenal coverage 4 pitch type(s)
Grayson RodriguezLos Angeles Angels vs Detroit Tigers28.440.410.54Slider (33% whiff, 11% usage)Savant whiff 20.9%, put-away 14.9%, xwOBA 0.394, arsenal coverage 4 pitch type(s)
Zack LittellWashington Nationals vs Athletics26.832.617.05Slider (22% whiff, 29% usage)Savant whiff 17.5%, put-away 14.0%, xwOBA 0.381, arsenal coverage 5 pitch type(s)
Tomoyuki SuganoColorado Rockies vs Cincinnati Reds22.130.29.07Split-Finger (30% whiff, 20% usage)Savant whiff 17.4%, put-away 11.6%, xwOBA 0.397, arsenal coverage 7 pitch type(s)
Shane BieberToronto Blue Jays vs Chicago White Sox20.243.60.05Curveball (41% whiff, 19% usage)Savant whiff 23.0%, put-away 13.9%, xwOBA 0.477, arsenal coverage 5 pitch type(s)

Diagnostic only. This is a free Savant-derived pitch-quality layer, not Pitcher List PLV/PLA, and it does not change recommendations.

PITCHER ASSESSMENT DIAGNOSTICS

30 starter assessment(s) emitted by Pitcher Engine
PitcherTeamHandSeason K%Recent IPSeason IPK IPPitch CtLeashSavantContactHR VulnQualityFlags / Notes
Brandon PfaadtArizona Diamondbacks vs St. Louis CardinalsR18.9%3.55.45.159shortfull45.0055.00season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 3.5 IP/start
J.T. GinnAthletics vs Washington NationalsR21.3%5.05.35.384shortfull51.0049.00season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 5.0 IP/start
Owen MurphyAtlanta Braves vs Texas RangersR24.8%2.0-5.234shortfull77.5022.50season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 2.0 IP/start
Trevor RogersBaltimore Orioles vs Houston AstrosL19.3%6.05.35.5101deepfull47.5052.50season+recent+savant+savant_quality+hand-
Patrick SandovalBoston Red Sox vs Tampa Bay RaysL22.7%-4.35.694shortfull60.5039.50season+savant+savant_quality+handseason leash 4.3 IP/GS, low-K contact opponent 18.9%, recent_form_unavailable
Matthew BoydChicago Cubs vs Minnesota TwinsL21.4%5.55.15.292normalfull37.5062.50season+recent+savant+savant_quality+hand-
Davis MartinChicago White Sox vs Toronto Blue JaysR18.7%4.35.65.372shortfull46.0054.00season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 4.3 IP/start, low-K contact opponent 19.7%
Rhett LowderCincinnati Reds vs Colorado RockiesR19.4%3.34.84.555shortfull29.0071.00season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 3.3 IP/start
Gavin WilliamsCleveland Guardians vs Pittsburgh PiratesR29.6%5.26.06.087normalfull45.5054.50season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handpatient opponent BB% 9.5%
Logan AllenCleveland Guardians vs Pittsburgh PiratesL23.2%--5.896unknownfull54.5045.50season+savant+savant_quality+handpatient opponent BB% 9.5%, recent_form_unavailable
Tomoyuki SuganoColorado Rockies vs Cincinnati RedsR13.9%5.25.35.387normalfull9.0091.00season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handpatient opponent BB% 9.7%
Tarik SkubalDetroit Tigers vs Los Angeles AngelsL31.9%5.45.86.091normalfull68.5031.50season+recent+savant+savant_quality+hand-
Spencer ArrighettiHouston Astros vs Baltimore OriolesR23.5%5.05.55.484shortfull33.0067.00season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 5.0 IP/start, patient opponent BB% 10.1%
Grayson RodriguezLos Angeles Angels vs Detroit TigersR18.4%4.14.44.769shortfull10.5089.50season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 4.1 IP/start, patient opponent BB% 9.5%
Emmet SheehanLos Angeles Dodgers vs New York YankeesR27.2%4.54.84.876shortfull54.5045.50season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 4.5 IP/start, patient opponent BB% 10.2%
Max MeyerMiami Marlins vs Milwaukee BrewersR25.6%5.85.76.097normalfull56.5043.50season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handpatient opponent BB% 10.7%
Shane DrohanMilwaukee Brewers vs Miami MarlinsL21.9%5.35.05.289normalfull64.5035.50season+recent+savant+savant_quality+hand-
Taj BradleyMinnesota Twins vs Chicago CubsR28.9%6.25.76.0104deepfull55.5044.50season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handpatient opponent BB% 11.0%
Sean ManaeaNew York Mets vs Philadelphia PhilliesL21.6%5.15.35.486shortfull48.5051.50season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 5.1 IP/start
Ryan WeathersNew York Yankees vs Los Angeles DodgersL27.3%4.55.45.276shortfull45.5054.50season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 4.5 IP/start, patient opponent BB% 10.4%
JesΓΊs LuzardoPhiladelphia Phillies vs New York MetsL32.3%6.25.86.0104deepfull73.0027.00season+recent+savant+savant_quality+hand-
Jared JonesPittsburgh Pirates vs Cleveland GuardiansR26.1%4.24.44.670shortfull60.0040.00season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 4.2 IP/start, patient opponent BB% 9.8%
Griffin CanningSan Diego Padres vs Kansas City RoyalsR21.5%4.34.74.672shortfull41.0059.00season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 4.3 IP/start
Logan WebbSan Francisco Giants vs Seattle MarinersR18.4%6.66.36.3111deepfull53.0047.00season+recent+savant+savant_quality+hand-
Bryan WooSeattle Mariners vs San Francisco GiantsR23.6%5.45.85.791normalfull61.5038.50season+recent+savant+savant_quality+hand-
Dustin MaySt. Louis Cardinals vs Arizona DiamondbacksR24.6%5.05.25.184shortfull57.0043.00season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 5.0 IP/start, low-K contact opponent 19.6%
Ian SeymourTampa Bay Rays vs Boston Red SoxL28.6%5.14.34.986shortfull62.0038.00season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 5.1 IP/start
MacKenzie GoreTexas Rangers vs Atlanta BravesL25.8%5.45.25.391normalfull54.5045.50season+recent+savant+savant_quality+hand-
Shane BieberToronto Blue Jays vs Chicago White SoxR18.9%4.14.45.069shortfull0.00100.00season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 4.1 IP/start
Zack LittellWashington Nationals vs AthleticsR16.2%4.84.74.780shortfull17.0083.00season+recent+savant+savant_quality+handrecent leash 4.8 IP/start

Diagnostics only. These values are exposed for review and do not change recommendations yet.

FULL AUDIT — ALL CANDIDATES

17 candidates evaluated
← Back to Picks
GradeSignalTypeSideGameTime (ET)LineProjOddsBest Book / LineEdge/DiffSignal Breakdown ✓!✗–Tier
► Best Signals
Aβœ… Best Signal
K final QC: opposing lineup not confirmed, juiced K over -136, expected IP 5.2 below A-grade leash
K PropSpencer Arrighetti OverORI@AST4:11 PM5.56.8-136DK Over 5.5 -136 | exact24.0%Best Signal
► Add Signals
BπŸ”¬ Research Only
Matchup: Opp lineup wRC+ 106 vs RHP β€” neutral | [!] Pitch-type: opp whiffs below avg vs SP top pitch (Γ—0.94) βœ— Over Ks
K PropShane Bieber UnderSOX@JAY3:08 PM4.53.3+114DK Under 4.5 +114 | exact26.3%!!Add Signal
Bβœ… Add Signal
K final QC: opposing lineup not confirmed, juiced K over -143, active roster BVP K% 15.8% over 133 PA
K PropJesus Luzardo OverMET@PHI4:06 PM6.58.1-143FanDuel Over 6.5 -136 | best price25.2%!Add Signal
Bβœ… Add Signal
Matchup: Pitch-type: opp whiffs above avg vs SP top pitch (Γ—1.08) βœ“ Over Ks | [!] Opp lineup wRC+ 114 vs RHP β€” tough platoon matc…
K PropMax Meyer OverMAR@BRE4:11 PM5.56.9-128FanDuel Over 5.5 -120 | best price24.9%!!Add Signal
BπŸ”¬ Research Only
Matchup: Opp lineup wRC+ 104 vs RHP β€” neutral | [!] Pitch-type: opp whiffs below avg vs SP top pitch (Γ—0.92) βœ— Over Ks
K PropTaj Bradley OverTWI@CUB2:21 PM5.56.7-146FanDuel Over 5.5 -142 | best price22.0%!Add Signal
► Lean Signals (Derisked)
C (Review)β†˜ Lean Signal - Derisked
Model edge fail: diff_pct 20.1% vs 17% min using selected line 4.5 clears, but raw gap +0.90 <= 1 min β€” posture note at D
K PropShane Drohan OverMAR@BRE4:11 PM4.55.4-127FanDuel Over 4.5 -122 | best price20.1%!Lean Signal - Derisked
C (Review)β†˜ Lean Signal - Derisked
Model edge fail: diff_pct 18.2% vs 17% min using selected line 4.5 clears, but raw gap +0.82 <= 1 min β€” posture note at D
K PropJT Ginn OverNAT@ATH10:06 PM4.55.3+116FanDuel Over 4.5 +130 | best price18.2%!Lean Signal - Derisked
C (Review)β†˜ Lean Signal - Derisked
Model edge fail: diff_pct 17.3% vs 17% min using selected line 5.5 clears, but raw gap -0.95 <= 1 min β€” posture note at D
K PropBryan Woo UnderGIA@MAR8:09 PM5.54.5+108DK Under 5.5 +108 | exact17.3%!Lean Signal - Derisked
C (Review)β†˜ Lean Signal - Derisked
Model edge fail: Insufficient model edge β€” diff_pct 13.7% vs 17% min using selected line 5.5 β€” posture note at D
K PropIan Seymour OverRAY@SOX4:11 PM5.56.2+121FanDuel Over 4.5 -156 | alt rescue13.7%!Lean Signal - Derisked
C (Review)β†˜ Lean Signal - Derisked
Model edge fail: Insufficient model edge β€” diff_pct 11.9% vs 17% min using selected line 4.5 β€” posture note at D
K PropGrayson Rodriguez UnderTIG@ANG10:08 PM4.54.0+116FanDuel Under 4.5 +118 | best price11.9%!!Lean Signal - Derisked
C (Review)β†˜ Lean Signal - Derisked
Model edge fail: Insufficient model edge β€” diff_pct 11.4% vs 17% min using selected line 4.5 β€” posture note at D
K PropTrevor Rogers OverORI@AST4:11 PM4.55.0-102Bovada Direct Over 4.5 +110 | best price11.4%Lean Signal - Derisked
C (Review)β†˜ Lean Signal - Derisked
Model edge fail: Insufficient model edge β€” diff_pct 9.5% vs 17% min using selected line 5.5 β€” posture note at D
K PropSean Manaea UnderMET@PHI4:06 PM5.55.0-165FanDuel Under 5.5 -158 | best price9.5%!Lean Signal - Derisked
C (Review)β†˜ Lean Signal - Derisked
Model edge fail: Insufficient model edge β€” diff_pct 9.0% vs 17% min using selected line 5.5 β€” posture note at D
K PropMatthew Boyd OverTWI@CUB2:21 PM5.56.0+129FanDuel Over 4.5 -166 | alt rescue9.0%!Lean Signal - Derisked
C (Review)β†˜ Lean Signal - Derisked
Model edge fail: Insufficient model edge β€” diff_pct 6.1% vs 17% min using selected line 5.5 β€” posture note at D
K PropLogan Webb UnderGIA@MAR8:09 PM5.55.2-108FanDuel Under 5.5 -104 | best price6.1%!Lean Signal - Derisked
► Watch Signals
B (Review)β—‡ Watch Signal
Model edge fail: diff_pct 20.8% vs 17% min using selected line 3.5 clears, but raw gap +0.73 <= 1 min β€” posture note at D
K PropDavis Martin OverSOX@JAY3:08 PM3.54.2-129FanDuel Over 3.5 -128 | best price20.8%Watch Signal
B (Review)β—‡ Watch Signal
Model edge fail: Insufficient model edge β€” diff_pct 12.8% vs 17% min using selected line 3.5 β€” posture note at D
K PropPatrick Sandoval OverRAY@SOX4:11 PM3.54.0-161FanDuel Over 3.5 -142 | best price12.8%Watch Signal
B (Review)β—‡ Watch Signal
Model edge fail: Insufficient model edge β€” diff_pct 11.7% vs 17% min using selected line 8.5 β€” posture note at D
K PropTarik Skubal OverTIG@ANG10:08 PM8.59.5+107FanDuel Over 7.5 -178 | alt rescue11.7%Watch Signal

✓ Supports   ! Mixed   ✗ Opposes   – No Data  |  Layer order: Line Fit | Model Edge | Market Alignment | Matchup | Availability | Game Context